Em's heading off to school this morning when she drops the bomb that she's in the spelling bee today. "Do you want me to be there?" I ask, sort of knowing the answer already. "Hannah's terrified her dad will show up with the camcorder again." she says flatly. I guess "no" was her answer--I'm getting better on teen-speak and deciphering what she is really saying beyond the words she utters. So, I wish her luck, share a chuckle about the spelling bee, and send her on her way.
I hate Em's school. It just seems to get more and more pathetic as time rolls on, and I am literally counting the days until she is out. I'm disgusted at the level of education and the catering to certain ethnic groups. "Celebrate Diversity" the sign says over the gym, which like the teen-speak jargon really means "Celebrate Only Certain Diversities". I keep heckling/suggesting to the Superintendent that we really need to have a Baltic States Heritage Celebration, but he just rolls his eyes.
The spelling bee is no exception to the catering. Emma and her friend, Hannah, are excellent students--tied for number one in the class. I'm not bragging, it is not my accomplishment--it just makes a point for the story.
Every year, the teachers dredge up some long-forsaken souls to "win" the spelling bee, and it is never the kids who are truly talented. Names appear on the winner's list that I have never heard of before, and I'm not exaggerating when I tell you I think a kid from special ed took the crown last year. It is more about being ethnically aware and pushing some kids to the top that otherwise would never see such glory otherwise. I'm okay with that--every award cannot be won by just the two top girls, they need to spread out the accolades so as to not "discourage" the rest of the student population. Why they don't actually teach the rest of the kids to excel is another question, but I think it might be asking a little much of everyone involved.
Anywho, Em comes home to give the full report, and I wait to give her the speech about "letting some other kids win for a change". She starts out with her placing (fifth), and Hannah's placing (third), and goes on to name the winners. Poor second-place kid's mom shows up at the middle school to cheer him on and now is officially on the social suicide top 10 list. "Stephen got words like 'it' and 'the', " she says, "while Hannah and I were given 'existentialism' or 'perihelion'!" She's miffed "It was sooo rigged," she continues, "no wonder the idiots win! It's a complete set-up!" Yeah, she understands completely for only being thirteen and eight months. She's empathetic and kind, and Em doesn't mind the loss--it's the ridiculousness of the whole charade that she cannot tolerate.
Back in the classroom, her English teacher continues to have her own spelling/language bee to include everyone--you know, so nobody feels excluded. Hands were shooting up left and right, eager to answer and beat out the group of smart girls who usually win all of the time. One particular knucklehead keeps his arm half up, sorta like he's scratching his back so that when the teacher finishes the question, he's got a milli-second edge on anyone else to get his arm in the air. He's killing and his score sails.
"Ha! Ha!" he's laughing like a fool, "It's like the 'ol turtle race and I'm the rabbit!" he's boasting. The rest of the class roars in confident arrogance.
Leave it to Caroline, she quietly replies "The rabbit loses, you idiot".
Somehow I think rigging the spelling bee isn't helping anyone.



12 comments:
Hi - I guess I need to write this again. My mind can't think too well at 1:00 a.m. You have a great blog...Thank you Lin for your comment and for visiting. Take care
"The rabbit loses, you idiot". ROFL
One of my daughters is in post grad doing her teacher's college. She tells similar horror stories of university, but it is based on financial aid. Emma (yes, her name is Emma, although I would never get away with calling her Em)has worked right through university and kept her debt load to a minimum. This makes her NOT ELIGIBLE for financial assistance. The kids who do not work, drink away their money, and take Winter Break trips to some exotic location, are handed money like there is no tomorrow. The final straw for her, was she arranged for a teaching placement in New Zealand. One would think this would be encouraged. A new teacher willing to experience new cultures, try something outside of her comfort zone, expand her mind, should be a valuable asset to students. Nope. Her request for travel funding was denied (and she only asked for what she knew most other people were asking for), while everyone else got travel dollars to teach in a school oh say, 2 or 3 hours from their homes.
/end of Panther rant
Once again, another beautifully written post which is why you soooo deserve the award I'm giving you. Grab it from my blog.
Oh my gosh, her comeback at the end. She's sassy like her momma!
I so empathize with you and your daughters. My question is, don't local spelling bee winners go on to state and eventually national competition? If the winners in your area were to compete at the national level they would be slaughtered.
I'm assuming this was just an in class spelling bee and not a real competition as Patricia pointed out because that school would certainly be a laughing stock if they sent inferior spellers to compete.
They certainly sound like they need to start teaching in a different manner and top students should definitely be rewarded. It does sound rigged.Your daughter seems to have a great sense of humor.
Just more proof of why I'm proud to call myself a homeschooling mommy! LOL! I can't believe they do that...that's just wrong IMHO! Happy day to you! I replied to your comment on my blog. :)
It reminds me of Little League when my son was about 10. They did not keep score (though the parents sure did) and since no score was kept no team won. At the end of the year EVERY kid in the whole league, about 200 kids, got a trophy, a huge trophy I might ad that they expected me to dust.
Escudero--Thanks for visiting me!
Hey! Everyone--go to Escudero's site for really, really cool paintings!!!
Urban Panther--Isn't it frustrating?! Especially to watch your child going through this. Arrrghhh.
Veronica--Thanks for the award! I'm behind on posting a couple. Oops.
Violet--Caroline isn't even MINE! But she should be--she's just like me and Emma. I keep telling her that SHE is my true daughter!
Patricia--Well, if the district is "proud" of who they send, then there is no problem, I guess. I would be embarrassed, so I'm glad Em has no part in this whole charade. She'll do fine in spite of this cruddy school district.
Jude--I have fought and fought, but the school staff, school board, and superintendent see no problems. They just roll their eyes at me. I think Em won't win the tie for Valedictorian because I'm an activist at the school and they will hold it against her. Whatever. We know what she is and I'm proud of her no matter what. Screw the Spelingg be! (hee! hee!)
Sherrie--Yep, you are smart! We do a lot of other things at home, like you, to educate the kids--that's why Em is #1. You have to. Can't leave it up to schools these days--public or private.
Jen--Ugh. Double ugh. I remember t-ball and they wouldn't even call the kids OUT! We are sooo messing up kids these days, aren't we? I think Em and Caroline got it together, though. Aren't they a hoot?!
That sounds beyond frustrating. Wouldn't it be smart to hold separate spelling bees based on level if the special needs children must be included? I can't stand that everyone should win thing. Everyone should excel so they have a chance at winning. My goodness I am just as miffed and I'm not even involved. I so get your point and I loved her response to the kid in the class. That sounds like something my teenager would say. :D
I came back to read some of your posts to see where you must be coming from to get the attitude about race. Now I see. A shame you do not teach your (empathatic?) daughter not to call people "idiots" and not to assume that contests where she does not win are rigged.
Also, how about learning about "special ed" kids? My son with asperger's syndrome wins the spelling bee every year..he has a special gift.
You have heard of Helen Keller? SENSITIVITY AND DIVERSITY TRAINING NEEDED!!! Or maybe since you are so disappointed in the school where your child is in the top 2, you should homeschool like your friend?
Post a Comment